Skip to content
tellyflick
HomeDiscoverJournalLibraryActivityDiary
Search films, shows and peopleSign in
tellyflick

Keep track of every film and show you watch, and see what your friends love.

Follow TellyFlick
ExploreDiscoverJournalWhat to watch tonightComing upBrowse by genre
TellyFlickAboutGuidesTellyFlick PlusPrivacyTerms
Get the app
Coming soon toApp StoreGet it onGoogle Play
© 2026 TellyFlickFilm and TV data from TMDB. Streaming data by JustWatch. About · Privacy · Terms

Amish Affair

2024 · Robin Hays · 86 min

Trailer

Sign in to add this to your library, rate it and log it.

Sign in
Streaming data by JustWatch

Where to watch

Stream
Lifetime Movie ClubLifetime Movie Club Apple TV channelLifetime Movie Club Amazon Channel
Free
Hoopla
Rent
Amazon VideoGoogle Play MoviesYouTubeFandango At Home
Buy
Amazon VideoGoogle Play MoviesYouTubeFandango At Home

Availability in the United States. Streaming data by JustWatch. See all options

Where to watch it in every country ›
Adtellyflick.com
Watch it with a friend

Invite a friend to TellyFlick and see what you both want to watch.

Invite a friend

Hannah moves in with a charismatic Amish leader, Aaron, to help with his ailing wife. Seeking refuge after leaving her Amish community, Hannah is grateful to Aaron and his wife for opening their home to her and giving her work but as she tends to her household chores, the spark between her and Aaron is undeniable. Hannah knows their secret relationship has them both living in sin, so she decides to end it but when Aaron’s wife suspiciously dies, she finds herself framed for murder and fighting to prove her innocence.

Ryan McPartlinAaronMackenzie CardwellHannahMaemae RenfrowRachelEvelyn BurkeGraceSSebastian GreavesJacobDana StoutenburgSarahPaul JarrettAbrahamGigi NeilLauraEse AtawoSergeant RileyGeorgia WatersMiriam

Cast

Ryan McPartlinAaronMackenzie CardwellHannahMaemae RenfrowRachelEvelyn BurkeGraceSSebastian GreavesJacobDana StoutenburgSarahPaul JarrettAbrahamGigi NeilLauraEse AtawoSergeant RileyGeorgia WatersMiriam

More like this

An Amish Murder
2013 · Film
Witness
1985 · Film
Jesse Stone: Lost in Paradise
2015 · Film
Scum
1977 · Film
Love Finds You In Sugarcreek
2014 · Film
Outlaw Prophet: Warren Jeffs
2014 · Film
Crossword Mysteries: Proposing Murder
2019 · Film
Hello
2022 · Film
Buried Alive
1990 · Film
Site Unseen: An Emma Fielding Mystery
2017 · Film
Riddled with Deceit: A Martha's Vineyard Mystery
2020 · Film
The Postman Always Rings Twice
1946 · Film
Aurora Teagarden Mysteries: A Very Foul Play
2019 · Film
Aurora Teagarden Mysteries: Til Death Do Us Part
2021 · Film