Skip to content

Home Discover Journal Library Activity Diary

Search films, shows and peopleSign in

Keep track of every film and show you watch, and see what your friends love.

Follow TellyFlick

ExploreDiscover Journal What to watch tonight Coming up Browse by genre

TellyFlickAbout Guides TellyFlick Plus Privacy Terms

Get the app

Coming soon toApp StoreGet it onGoogle Play

© 2026 TellyFlickLanguageFilm and TV data from TMDB. Streaming data by JustWatch. About · Privacy · Terms

Love Finds You In Sugarcreek

2014 · Terry Cunningham · 91 min

Sign in to add this to your library, rate it and log it.

Sign in

Streaming data by JustWatch

Where to watch

Stream

Free

Rent

Buy

Availability in the United States. Streaming data by JustWatch. See all options

Where to watch it in every country ›

Adtellyflick.com

Watch it with a friend

Invite a friend to TellyFlick and see what you both want to watch.

Invite a friend

Will a mysterious stranger's past wreak havoc on a quiet Amish community after they've opened their doors -- and hearts -- to him and his son?

RatingsNo TellyFlick ratings yet

6.5/10Rating on TMDBFrom The Movie Database53 votes

Tom Everett ScottJoe Matthews / Micah Matthias

Sarah LancasterRachel Troyler

Thomas KapanowskiBobby Matthews / Bobby Matthias

Kelly McGillisBertha Troyler

Nicole BadaanKim

Annie KitralLydia Troyler KKatherine DeBoerChloe Styles MMarianna AlacchiAnna Troyler

Ken StrunkEli Troyler

Greg ViolandEd Spencer JJohn EbySam Phillips GGeoffrey HoffmanDylan Matthias KKaitlyn SappElise

Chris Van VlietReporter #1 JJeannie MadisonReporter #2

Cast

Tom Everett ScottJoe Matthews / Micah Matthias

Sarah LancasterRachel Troyler

Thomas KapanowskiBobby Matthews / Bobby Matthias

Kelly McGillisBertha Troyler

Nicole BadaanKim

Annie KitralLydia Troyler KKatherine DeBoerChloe Styles MMarianna AlacchiAnna Troyler

Ken StrunkEli Troyler

Greg ViolandEd Spencer JJohn EbySam Phillips GGeoffrey HoffmanDylan Matthias KKaitlyn SappElise

Chris Van VlietReporter #1 JJeannie MadisonReporter #2

More like this

Love Finds You in Charm

Miss Marple: They Do It with Mirrors

Garage Sale Mystery: A Case Of Murder

Aurora Teagarden Mysteries: A Very Foul Play

Three Bedrooms, One Corpse: An Aurora Teagarden Mystery

Riddled with Deceit: A Martha's Vineyard Mystery

Aurora Teagarden Mysteries: Reunited and It Feels So Deadly

The Caveman's Valentine

My Dinner with Hervé

Brand Upon the Brain!

Gourmet Detective: A Healthy Place to Die

The Good Witch's Family